Original Papers

Should justice for people come before justice for the environment? Engaging students in debates about environmental justice.


Abstract


This paper outlines the main differences between ecocentric and anthropocentric positions in regard to justice, exploring university students’ perceptions of the concepts of social and ecological justice and reflecting on how values assigned to humans and the environment are balanced and contested. Putting justice for people before the environment is based on evidence that biological conservation can disadvantage local communities; the idea that the very notion of justice is framed by humans and therefore remains a human issue; and the assumption that humans have a higher value than other species. Putting justice for the environment first assumes that only an ecocentric ethic guarantees protection of all species, including humans, and therefore ecological justice already guarantees social justice. This research shows that many students emphasize the convergence of social and ecological justice where human and environmental interests correspond. While not wishing to diminish the underlying assumptions of either ethical orientation, the common “enemy” of both vulnerable communities and nonhuman nature, as identified by students, is an ideology of economic growth and industrial development.


Full Text:

PDF


DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.13135/2384-8677/2688

References


Abram, S., Acciaioli, G., Baviskar, A., Kopnina, H., Nonini, D., Strang, V. 2016. ‘Special Module: Plenary Debate from the IUAES World Congress 2013: Evolving Humanity, Emerging Worlds, 5–10 August 2013’. Involving anthropology: debating anthropology’s assumptions, relevance and future. Anthropological Forum, 26(1): 74-95.

Baviskar, A. 2013. Hallsworth Plenary Debate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oldnYTYMx-k

Benjaminsen, T.A., Rohde, R., Espen, S., Wisborg, P., & Lebert, T. 2006. Land reform, range ecology, and carrying capacities in Namaqualand, South Africa. Annals of the Association of Amarican Geographers, 96(3), 524-540.

Benjaminsen, T. A., Kepe, T. and Bråthen, S. 2008. "Between Global Interests and Local Needs: Conservation and Land Reform in Namaqualand, South Africa." Africa: Journal of the International African Institute 78(2):223-44.

Butchvarov, P. 2015. Anthropocentrism in Philosophy. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter Books.

Cafaro, P. and Primack, R. 2014. Species extinction is a great moral wrong, Biological conservation 170: 1-2.

Colchester, M. 1994. Salvaging Nature: Indigenous Peoples, Protected Areas and Biodiversity Conservation. Diane Publishing, United States.

Crist, E. 2012. Abundant Earth and Population. In: Cafaro, P. and Christ, E. (ed.): Life on the Brink: Environmentalists confront Overpopulation. Athens: GA: University of Georgia Press. p. 141-153.

Desmond, J. 2013. Requiem for roadkill: Death and Denial on America's roads. In: Kopnina H, Shoreman-Ouimet E (eds) Environmental Anthropology: Future Directions, New York and Oxford: Routledge, pp. 46–58.

Devall, B. 1980. “The Deep Ecology Movement”, Natural Resources Journal, 20: 299 - 322.

Dietz R. and O’Neill D. 2013. Enough is enough: building a sustainable economy is a world of finite resources. San Francisco: Berrett-Koehler Publishers.

EPA. Environmental Protection Agency, "Environmental Justice." https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice.

Goodall, J. 2015. Caring for People and Valuing Forests in Africa. In G. Wuerthner, E. Crist and T. Butler (eds), Protecting the Wild: Parks and Wilderness, The Foundation for Conservation, Washington, London: The Island Press, pp. 21–26.

Guldberg, H. 2011. Only humans have morality, not animals. Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/reclaiming-childhood/201106/only-humans-have-morality-not-animals.

Grey, W. 1993. Anthropocentrism and Deep Ecology, Australiasian Journal of Philosophy 71(4):463 - 475.

Hansen, A. and Wethal, U. (eds.) (2014) Emerging Economies and Challenges to Sustainability: Theories, strategies, local realities. New York: Routledge.

Iphofen, R. 2013 Research Ethics in Ethnography/Anthropology. European Commission (http://ec.europa.eu/research/participants/data/ref/h2020/other/hi/ethics-guide-ethnog-anthrop_en.pdf)

Jonas, H., Roe, D. and Makagon, J.E. 2014. Human Rights Standards for Conservation: An Analysis of Responsibilities, Rights and Redress for Just Conservation. IIED Issue Paper. IIED, London.

Kant, I. 1772-1789. Lectures on Anthropology. In Cohen, A. ed., 2014. Kant's Lectures on Anthropology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Kidner, D.W. 2014. Why ‘anthropocentrism’is not anthropocentric. Dialectical anthropology, 38(4): 465-480.

Kopnina, H. and Shoreman-Ouimet, E. 2013. "Preface." Environmental Anthropology: Future Directions. New York: Routledge.

Kopnina, H. 2012. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD): The turn away from ‘environment’ in environmental education? Environmental Education Research, 18 (5): 699-717.

Kopnina, H. 2013. Hallsworth Plenary Debate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oldnYTYMx-k

Kopnina, H. 2014. Environmental Justice and Biospheric Egalitarianism: Reflecting on a Normative-philosophical View of Human-nature relationship. Earth Perspectives. 1: 8.

Kopnina, H and Blewitt, J. 2014. Sustainable Business: Key Issues. New York: Routledge.

Kopnina, H. and Washington, H. 2016. Discussing why population growth is still ignored or denied. Chinese Journal of Population, Resources and Environment, 14(2): 133-143.

Kopnina, H. 2017. Teaching Sustainable Development Goals in The Netherlands: a critical approach. Special Issue: Environmental and Sustainability Education in the BENELUX region. Environmental Education Research, http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13504622.2017.1303819

Kortenkamp, K. and Moore, C. 2001. Ecocentrism and Anthropocentrism: Moral Reasoning About Ecological Commons Dilemmas, Journal of Environmental Psychology 21: 261 - 272.

Kumar, M. and Kumar, P. 2008. Valuation of the ecosystem services: a psycho-cultural perspective," Ecological economics 64(4): 808-819.

Latour, B. 1991. Nous n'avons jamais été modernes: Essai d'anthropologie symétrique. Harvard, MA: Harvard University Press.

Mathews, F. 2016. From biodiversity-based conservation to an ethic of bio-proportionality. Biological Conservation, 200:140-148.

McDonough W. and Braungart M. 2002. Cradle to cradle: remaking the way we make things. London: Vintage Books.

Ming Lam, L. and Paul, S. 2014. Disputed Land Rights and Conservation-led Displacement: A Double Whammy on the Poor. Conservation & Society. 12(1): 65–76.

Minteer, B.A. & Manning, R.E. 2000. Convergence in environmental values: An empirical and conceptual defense. Ethics, Place and Environment, 3(1): 47-60.

Monbiot, G. "Is Protecting the Environment Incompatible with Social Justice?" The Guardian. February 13, 2012. https://www.theguardian.com/environment/georgemonbiot/2012/feb/13/protecting-environment-social-justice

Naess, A. 1973. The shallow and the deep: long-range ecology movement. A summary, Inquiry, 16:95–99.

Nonini, D. 2013. Hallsworth Plenary Debate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oldnYTYMx-k

Norton, B. 1991. Toward Unity among Environmentalists, New York: Oxford University Press.

Norton, B. 1984. “Environmental Ethics and Weak Anthropocentrism”, Environmental Ethics Vol. 6, pp. 132 - 148.

Peluso, N. L. 1993. Coercing conservation?: The politics of state resource control. Global Environmental Change, 3(2): 199-217.

Poirier, N. and Tomasello, S. 2017. Polar Similar: Intersections of Anthropology and Conservation. Animalia, 1-17.

Sartre, J.-P. 1943. L'Être et le néant: Essai d'ontologie phénoménologique. Paris: Gallimard.

Saunders, B., Kitzinger, J. and Kitzinger, C., 2015. Anonymising interview data: Challenges and compromise in practice. Qualitative Research, 15(5):616-632.

Schlosberg, D. 2004. Reconceiving environmental justice: global movements and political theories. Environmental politics. 13(3): 517-540.

Selin, H. ed. 2003. Nature Across Cultures. Science Across Cultures: The History of Non-Western Science. Dordrecht: Springer Netherlands.

Shoreman-Ouimet, E. and Kopnina, H. 2015. Reconciling Ecological and Social Justice to Promote Biodiversity Conservation. Biological Conservation, 184: 320–326.

Simkins, A. 2013. Anthropocentrism and the Place of Humans in the Biblical Tradition, Journal of Religion & Society 9:17 - 29.

Sponsel, L. E. 2014. Human Impact on Biodiversity: Overview, In Encyclopedia of Biodiversity, Waltham, MA: Academic Press 4:137-152.

Strang, V. 2013. Hallsworth Plenary Debate. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oldnYTYMx-k

Strang, V. 2016. Justice for all: inconvenient truths and reconciliations in human and non-human relations. In Routledge Handbook of Environmental Anthropology. Ed. by H. Kopnina and E. Shoreman-Ouimet. Oxford, New York: Routledge.

Westra, L. 1998. Living in integrity: a global ethic to restore a fragmented earth. Lanham, Maryland: Rowman & Littlefield.

Wienhues, A. 2017. Sharing the Earth: A Biocentric Account of Ecological Justice. Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics, 30(3):367-385.

World Bank. "Poverty Overview." Accessed Web. 19 Oct. 2016. .

Wang U (2012) Report: 180 Solar Panel Makers Will Disappear By 2015. Forbes.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/uciliawang/2012/10/16/report-180-solar-panel-makers-will-disappear-by-2015/. Accessed 17 May 2017

Washington H 2015. Demystifying Sustainability: Towards Real Solutions. Routledge, London.

WEF (World Economic Forum) 2013. Energy

Harnessing: New Solutions for Sustainability and Growing Demand

http://www3.weforum.org/docs/WEF_EN_EnergyHarnessing_Report_2013.pdf

Accessed 17 May 2017


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.