Can the Dow Jones Sustainable Index be useful for evaluating Dow Jones Islamic Market companies?

Maura Campra; Sabrina Pucci; Valerio Brescia

doi:10.13135/2421-2172/4156

Maura Campra Department of Economics and Business Studies, University of Piemonte Orientale “Amedeo Avogadro”, Novara, Italy
Sabrina Pucci School of Economics and Business Studies, University of Roma Tre, Rome, Italy
Valerio Brescia Department of Management University of Turin https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7919-5370

DOI: https://doi.org/10.13135/2421-2172/4156

Keywords: Sustainability, finance, Dow Jones Islamic Market, Dow Jones Sustainable Index, social indicators

Abstract

In recent years, the focus on sustainability and social impact has increased, companies through environmental programs and social practices have also begun to change their model in response to the demands of stakeholders and the market. A more sustainable approach is also driven by the 17 goals defined by UNESCO in the Sustainable Development Goals. The idea of sustainability derives directly from the concept of CSR (Corporate Social Responsibility), a real way of doing business in a strategic way, which consists in acting responsibly from a social and environmental point of view and in building solid and long-term relationships between companies and stakeholders, from the supplier to the final consumer. The "Mediterranean Commission for Sustainable Development" (MCSD) established in 1995 started the project "Sustainable development indicators" (SDI), which aims to develop indicators of progress towards sustainable development in the countries of Europe, Africa and Asia that face the Mediterranean, offering the great opportunity to compare developments in the process of integrating the environment into profoundly different national reality policies. Currently, the most widespread worldwide of all the SDI indicators is the Dow Jones Sustainability Index (DJSI), established in 1999. The index is the first to assess the financial performance of global companies that follow sustainable principles. Unfortunately, all the studies conducted through the use of DJSI to evaluate the main sustainable firms do not consider the Sharia compliant market but are based only on the Dow Jones market. Therefore, there is no sustainability model that takes into account the companies that have had access to the Dow Jones Islamic Market. This Gap in literature and in practice does not allow us to confirm or contribute further to the use of the sustainability indicator with models that are particularly sensitive to the sharia compliant criteria. The statistical analysis has verified a difference between companies belonging to the Dow Jones Market and the Dow Jones Islamic Market model. This difference confirms the interest in testing the behaviour of the social and environmental sustainability index as well as the economic one even in companies belonging to the sharia-compliant market. The qualitative analysis of the models allows a possible future adoption in these markets based on scientific and literary evidence.

Author Biographies

Maura Campra, Department of Economics and Business Studies, University of Piemonte Orientale “Amedeo Avogadro”, Novara, Italy

Full professor

Sabrina Pucci, School of Economics and Business Studies, University of Roma Tre, Rome, Italy

Full professor

References

C. Gimenez, V. Sierra, e J. Rodon, «Sustainable operations: Their impact on the triple bottom line», International Journal of Production Economics, vol. 140, n. 1, pagg. 149–159, 2012.

A. J. Sulkowski, M. Edwards, e R. E. Freeman, «Shake your stakeholder: Firms leading engagement to cocreate sustainable value», Organization & Environment, vol. 31, n. 3, pagg. 223–241, 2018.

D. Griggs et al., «Policy: Sustainable development goals for people and planet», Nature, vol. 495, n. 7441, pag. 305, 2013.

M. Nilsson, D. Griggs, e M. Visbeck, «Policy: map the interactions between Sustainable Development Goals», Nature, vol. 534, n. 7607, pagg. 320–322, 2016.

European Commission, Special Eurobarometer 468, Survey requested by the European Commission, Directorate-General for Environment and co-ordinated by the Directorate- General for Communication. 2017.

E. H. Creyer, «The influence of firm behavior on purchase intention: do consumers really care about business ethics?», Journal of consumer Marketing, 1997.

L. A. Mohr, D. J. Webb, e K. E. Harris, «Do consumers expect companies to be socially responsible? The impact of corporate social responsibility on buying behavior», Journal of Consumer affairs, vol. 35, n. 1, pagg. 45–72, 2001.

C. B. Bhattacharya e S. Sen, «Consumer–company identification: A framework for understanding consumers’ relationships with companies», Journal of marketing, vol. 67, n. 2, pagg. 76–88, 2003.

K. M. Howie, L. Yang, S. J. Vitell, V. Bush, e D. Vorhies, «Consumer participation in cause-related marketing: An examination of effort demands and defensive denial», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 147, n. 3, pagg. 679–692, 2018.

M. J. Epstein, Making sustainability work: Best practices in managing and measuring corporate social, environmental and economic impacts. Routledge, 2018.

D. Hofenk, M. van Birgelen, J. Bloemer, e J. Semeijn, «How and when retailers’ sustainability efforts translate into positive consumer responses: the interplay between personal and social factors», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 156, n. 2, pagg. 473–492, 2019.

M. J. Masanet-Llodra, «Environmental management accounting: a case study research on innovative strategy», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 68, n. 4, pagg. 393–408, 2006.

A. J. Hoffman, «Linking organizational and field-level analyses: The diffusion of corporate environmental practice», Organization & Environment, vol. 14, n. 2, pagg. 133–156, 2001.

S. Hanson, L. Jiang, J. Ye, e N. Murthy, «Society or the environment? Understanding how consumers evaluate brand messages about corporate social responsibility activities», Journal of Brand Management, vol. 26, n. 1, pagg. 21–34, 2019.

M. Van Marrewijk, «Concepts and definitions of CSR and corporate sustainability: Between agency and communion», Journal of business ethics, vol. 44, n. 2–3, pagg. 95–105, 2003.

J. H. Behagel e B. Arts, «Democratic governance and political rationalities in the implementation of the water framework directive in the netherlands», Public Administration, vol. 92, n. 2, pagg. 291–306, 2014, doi: 10.1111/padm.12059.

European Commission, LIBRO VERDE Promuovere un quadro europeo per la responsabilità sociale delle imprese. 2001.

D. Gonzalez-Rodriguez e J. R. Hernandez-Carrion, «Self-Organized Linguistic Systems: From traditional AI to bottom-up generative processes», Futures, vol. 103, pagg. 27–34, 2018, doi: 10.1016/j.futures.2018.03.003.

K. W. Robert, T. M. Parris, e A. A. Leiserowitz, «What is sustainable development? Goals, indicators, values, and practice», Environment: science and policy for sustainable development, vol. 47, n. 3, pagg. 8–21, 2005.

A. Bhimani e K. Langfield-Smith, «Structure, formality and the importance of financial and non-financial information in strategy development and implementation», Management accounting research, vol. 18, n. 1, pagg. 3–31, 2007.

C. Hoffmann e C. Fieseler, «Investor relations beyond financials», Corporate Communications: An International Journal, 2012.

A. Charles, O. Darné, e A. Pop, «Risk and ethical investment: Empirical evidence from Dow Jones Islamic indexes», Research in International Business and Finance, vol. 35, pagg. 33–56, 2015.

S. Secinaro, Equity crowdfunding Sharia compliant, vol. 1. G Giappichelli Editore, 2017.

P. Biancone, S. Secinaro, e V. Brescia, «Introduction of Islamic finance in Brexit time, some tips for the West», International Journal of Management Sciences and Business Research, 2019.

A. A. Rahman, M. A. Yahya, e M. H. M. Nasir, «Islamic norms for stock screening», International Journal of Islamic and Middle Eastern Finance and Management, 2010.

Valerio Brescia, «Top performer companies in the Dow Jones Market and the Dow Jones Islamic Market». Zenodo, 2019.

S. Wallot e G. Leonardi, «Deriving inferential statistics from recurrence plots: A recurrence-based test of differences between sample distributions and its comparison to the two-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test», Chaos: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Nonlinear Science, vol. 28, n. 8, pag. 085712, 2018.

V. Amor-Esteban, M.-P. Galindo-Villardón, I.-M. García-Sánchez, e F. David, «An extension of the industrial corporate social responsibility practices index: New information for stakeholder engagement under a multivariate approach», Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 26, n. 1, pagg. 127–140, 2019.

L. S. Mahoney e L. Thorne, «Corporate social responsibility and long-term compensation: Evidence from Canada», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 57, n. 3, pagg. 241–253, 2005.

A. Russo e F. Perrini, «Investigating stakeholder theory and social capital: CSR in large firms and SMEs», Journal of Business ethics, vol. 91, n. 2, pagg. 207–221, 2010.

R. Ciegis, J. Ramanauskiene, e G. Startiene, «Theoretical reasoning of the use of indicators and indices for sustainable development assessment», Engineering Economics, vol. 63, n. 4, 2009.

S. J. Fowler e C. Hope, «A critical review of sustainable business indices and their impact», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 76, n. 3, pagg. 243–252, 2007.

M. Schröder, «Is there a difference? The performance characteristics of SRI equity indices», Journal of Business Finance & Accounting, vol. 34, n. 1–2, pagg. 331–348, 2007.

B. LeBaron, «The stability of moving average technical trading rules on the Dow Jones Index», Derivatives Use, Trading and Regulation, vol. 5, n. 4, pagg. 324–338, 2000.

M. J. Fishman e K. M. Hagerty, «Disclosure decisions by firms and the competition for price efficiency», The Journal of Finance, vol. 44, n. 3, pagg. 633–646, 1989.

R. A. Dye, «Disclosure of nonproprietary information», Journal of accounting research, pagg. 123–145, 1985.

D. S. Gelb e J. A. Strawser, «Corporate social responsibility and financial disclosures: An alternative explanation for increased disclosure», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 33, n. 1, pagg. 1–13, 2001.

P. Sengupta, «Corporate Disclosure Quality and the Cost of Debt», Accounting Review, October, 1998.

W. G. Simpson e T. Kohers, «The link between corporate social and financial performance: Evidence from the banking industry», Journal of business ethics, vol. 35, n. 2, pagg. 97–109, 2002.

A. W. K. Cheung, «Do stock investors value corporate sustainability? Evidence from an event study», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 99, n. 2, pagg. 145–165, 2011.

R. Garcia-Castro, M. A. Ariño, e M. A. Canela, «Does social performance really lead to financial performance? Accounting for endogeneity», Journal of Business Ethics, vol. 92, n. 1, pagg. 107–126, 2010.

M. P. Miles e J. G. Covin, «Environmental marketing: A source of reputational, competitive, and financial advantage», Journal of business ethics, vol. 23, n. 3, pagg. 299–311, 2000.

R. Debreceny, G. L. Gray, e A. Rahman, «The determinants of Internet financial reporting», Journal of Accounting and Public policy, vol. 21, n. 4–5, pagg. 371–394, 2002.

M. del Mar Alonso-Almeida, J. Llach, e F. Marimon, «A closer look at the ‘Global Reporting Initiative’sustainability reporting as a tool to implement environmental and social policies: A worldwide sector analysis», Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, vol. 21, n. 6, pagg. 318–335, 2014.

A. Hassan, «Impact of ethical screening on investment performance: the case of the Dow Jones Islamic Index», Islamic Economic Studies, vol. 12, 2005.

R. Siddiqui, «Shari’ah Compliance, Performance, and Conversion: The Case of the Dow Jones Islamic Market Index», Chi. J. Int’l L., vol. 7, pag. 495, 2006.

P. Biancone, La banca islamica, European I. Torino: G. Giappichelli Editore, 2017.

V. J. Sadeghi e P. P. Biancone, «Shariah Compliant International Entrepreneurship: A Study of Islamic Finance in Europe», European Journal of Islamic Finance, vol. 8, 2017.

P. Biancone e M. Radwan, «International Entrepreneurship from an Islamic (Sharia Compliant) Prospective “The Opportunities for Western Economies”», 2017.

P. P. Biancone e M. Radwan, «European companies: evaluation for sharia compliance “opportunities and challenges”», European Journal of Islamic Finance, n. 5, 2016.

K. M. Hassan e E. Girard, «Faith-based ethical investing: The case of Dow Jones Islamic indexes», Islamic Economic Studies, vol. 17, n. 2, 2010.

K. Hussein e M. Omran, «Ethical investment revisited: evidence from Dow Jones Islamic indexes», The Journal of Investing, vol. 14, n. 3, pagg. 105–126, 2005.

A. Guyot, «Efficiency and dynamics of Islamic investment: evidence of geopolitical effects on Dow Jones Islamic market indexes», Emerging Markets Finance and Trade, vol. 47, n. 6, pagg. 24–45, 2011.

T. Dyllick e K. Hockerts, «Beyond the business case for corporate sustainability», Business strategy and the environment, vol. 11, n. 2, pagg. 130–141, 2002.

L. Corvo e L. Pastore, «The challenge of Social Impact Bond: the state of the art of the Italian context», European Journal of Islamic Finance, 2019.