LA RELIGIONE COME PRETESTO: LE CAUSE ECONOMICHE, SOCIALI E POLITICHE DELLE GUERRE E DEI CONFLITTI NEL SUBCONTINENTE INDIANO

  • Marzia Casolari Università di Torino

Abstract

Communal strife is one of the most noteworthy political phenomenon in India at present. Since the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) return to power in 2014 India’s political climate worsened: attacks on religious minorities, in particular Muslims, and low caste members are the order of the day. At the same time, the relations between India and Pakistan are at one of their most critical stages: in February 2019 indeed a fifth Indo-Pakistani war almost broke out and thereafter the relations between the two countries are very tense.

Communalism in India dates back to the colonial times. Subsequent failures to resolve the problem of an increasing enmity between Hindu and Muslim community led to India’s partition and to recurrent riots within the country.

Communalism is often ascribed to religious causes, whereas religion is just a powerful mobilization tool. This essay aims to prove that the causes of apparently religious conflicts are economic, social and political. This applies in particular to India, as a strongly multiethnic country, but to any other multiethnic context as well.

In order to fight communalism, its real causes should be addressed.

References

Aziz, Qutbuddin, The Dangerous Nexus Between Israel and India, www.islamicity.org, 16 maggio 2001

Basu, Tapan, Datta, Pradip, Sarkar, Sumit, Sarkar, Tanika, Sen, Sambuddha (1993), Khaki Short and Saffron Flags. A Critique of the Hindu Right, New Delhi, Longman Orient

Bhattacharjee, Manash Firaq, How cow vigilantism is undermining the rule of law in India,“Aljazeera”, 23 gennaio 2019

Bhattacharyya, Rajeev, China-India Border Talks Remain Difficult Amid Map Burning Controversy, “The Diplomat”, 21 maggio 2019

Bisht, Akash, Kashmir lockdown: Stories of torture and arbitrary arrests, “Aljazeera”, 4 settembre 2019

Blanche, Ed, An Israeli-Indian intelligence-sharing affair unfolds in Kashmir, “Daily Star Lebanon”, 11 settembre 2001

Blank, Jonah, Let’s Talk About Kashmir, “The Rand Blog”, 8 settembre 2014

Burton, Guy, India’s “Look West” Policy in the Middle East under Modi, Middle East Institute Publications, 6 agosto 2019

Carnegy, Patrick (1870), A Historical Sketch of Tehsíl Fyzabad , including the former capitals, Ájúdhiá and Fyzabád, Allahabad, Lucknow, Oudh Government Press

Casolari, Marzia (2001), Aspetti giuridici e multiculturalismo. Il problema dell’unificazione del diritto di famiglia in India, in Elisabetta Basile, Michelguglielmo Torri (a c. di.), Il subcontinente indiano verso il terzo millennio. Tensioni politiche, trasformazioni sociali ed economiche, mutamento culturale, Milano, Franco Angeli

Id. (2015), Bangladesh 2014: Old Patterns, New Trends, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXV

Id. (2017), Bangladesh 2016: A laboratory for radical Islam, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXVII

Chandra, Bipin (1992), Communalism in Modern India, New Delhi, Vikas Publishing House

Chatterji, Probhat Chandra (1995), Secular Values for Secular India, New Delhi, Manohar

Chaudhuri, Pramit Pal, Think West to Go West: Origins and Implications of India’s West Asia Policy Under Modi (Part I), Middle East Institute Publications, 26 settembre 2017

Chaudhury, Dipanjan Roy, ISI’s covert act prompted Modi-Kyi anti-terror pact, “Economic Times”, 12 luglio 2018

Chengappa, Raj, Balakot: How India planned IAF air strike in Pakistan. An inside story, “India Today”, 18 marzo 2019

Chenoy, Kamal Mitra, Sukla S.P., Subramaniam K.S., Vinaik, Achin (2002), Gujarat carnage 2002. A report to the Nation by An Independent Fact Finding Mission. D.R. Goyal, Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh, South Asia Citizens Web, www.sacw.net

Corvino, Marco Valerio (2016) A brutal and violent year in the Kashmir Valley, in “Asia Maior”, vol. XXVII

Das, Shaswati, India, Sri Lanka begin joint probe into Easter bombings,“Livemint”, 20 maggio 2019

Dugger, Celia W., Shanker Thom, ‘Rumsfeld Sees Indivations of Qaeda’s Operating in Kashmir’, The New York Times, 13 giugno 2002

Fisk, Robert, Israel is playing a big role in India’s escalating conflict with Pakistan,“Independent”, 28 febbraio 2019

Ganguli, Sumit (2004), Storia dell’India e del Pakistan. Due paesi in conflitto, Torino, Bruno Mondadori

Gettlemanm Jeffrey, Schultz, Kai, Yasir, Sameer, Raj, Suhasini, India’s Move in Kashmir: More Than 2,000 Rounded Up With No Recourse, “The New York Times”, 23 agosto 2019

Hardgrave, Robert L. (1977), The Mapilla Rebellion, 1921: Peasant Revolt in Malabar, “Modern Asian Studies, Vol. 11, n. 1

Hasan, Mushirul (1996), Minority Identity and its Discontents: Ayodhya and its Aftermath, in Bidwai, Mukhia, Vanaik (a cura di), Religion, Religiosity and Communalism, New Delhi, Manohar

Jaffrelot, Christophe (2009), The India-US Rapprochement: State-driven or Middle Class-driven?, “India Quartely”, 1 gennaio 2009

Jamal, Arif A., Criminalising talaq Muslim divorce in India is overkill, “South China Morning Post”, 7 agosto 2019

Jenkins, Lin, Thousands of tourists flee Kashmir after security alert, “The Guardian”, 3 agosto 2019

Kumaraswami P. R., India’s New Israel Policy, Stiftung Wissenschaft and Politick Comment, n. 11, marzo 2019

La Vena, Pier Antonio, Ayodhya: origine, evoluzione e strumentalizzazione del mito del Janmasthan, tesi di laurea, Università degli Studi di Torino, AA 2016-2017, pp. 27-30

Maiorano, Diego, Torri, Michelguglielmo (2015), India 2014: the annihilation of the congress party and the beginning of the Modi Era, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXV

Id. (2016), India 2015: The uncertain record of the Modi government, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXVI

Id. (2017), India 2016: Reforming the economy and tightening the connection with the US, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXVII

Id. (2018), India 2017: Narendra Modi’s continuing hegemony and his challenge to China, “Asia Maior” vol. XXVIII

Mallawarachi, Bharata, India, Sri Lanka Agree to Step Up Anti-Terrorism Efforts, “The Diplomat”, 10 giugno 2019

Miller, Alistair (2009), Developing Regional Counterterrorism Cooperation in South Asia, Combating Terrorism Center, vol. 2, n. 12

Miller, Roland E. (2015), Mapilla Muslim Culture. How a Historic Muslim Community in India Has Blended Tradition and Modernity, New York, Suny Press

Montgomery Martin, Robert (1838), History, Antiquities, Topography and Statistics of Eastern India, voll. I-III, London

Mukhopadhyay, Nilanjan (1994), Demolition. India at the Crossroads, New Delhi, Indus

Narain, Akanksha, Rivival of Violence in Kashmir: The Threat of India’s Security, “Counter Terrorist Trends and Analyses”, International Centre for Political Violence and Terrorism Research, vol. 8, n. 7, luglio 2016

Osuri, Goldie, Kashmir and Palestine: The story of two occupations, “Aljazeera”, 24 agosto 2016

Pande, Aparna (2018), Natural Allies? The India-US Relations from the Clinton Administration to the Trump Era, “Notes de l’Ifri”, Asie.Visions, 104, dicembre 2018

Pandey, Gita, Article 370: What happend with Kashmir and why matters, “BBC News”, 5 agosto 2019

Pandey, Gyanendra (1999), The Construction of Communalism in Colonial North India, New Delhi, Oxford University Press

Pant, Harsh V., Mohanti Baisali (2017), Building a BIMSTEC Agenda for Counterterrorism, “ORF Issue Brief” n. 212, Observer Research Foundation, novembre 2917

Rajeshwari, B. (2004), Communal Riots in India. A Chronology (1947-2003), Institute of peace and Conflict Studies (IPCS) Research Papers

Ratcliffe, Rebecca, Kashmir: Imran Khan says Pakistan will ‘teach India a lesson’, “The Guardian”, 14 agosto 2019

Reghukumar, Neethu, Govt Trying to Convert Jammu and Kashmir into India’s Palestine, Says CPM’s Sitaram Yechury, “News18”, 20 agosto 2019

Saberin, Zeenat, Narendra Modi’s BJP party suffers setback in by-election, “Aljazeera”, 31 maggio 2018

Schofield, Victoria (2004), Kashmir: India, Pakistan e la guerra infinita, Roma, Fazi

Singh, Sushant, Pakistan F-16 controversy: Three key questions, evidence on the ground and in the air, “The Indian Express”, 7 aprile 2019

Siyech, Mohammed Sinan, Al-Qaeda in the Indian Subcontinent (AQIS): Renewing Efforts in India, sito web del Middle East Institute, https://www.mei.edu/publications/, 19 settembre 2017

Spodek, Howard (2010), In the Hidutva Laboratory: Pogroms and Politics in Gujarat, 2002, “Modern Asian Studies”, Vol. 44, No. 2

Torri, Michelguglielmo (2019), India 2018: The resetting of New Delhi’s foreign policy?, “Asia Maior”, vol. XXIX

Tramballi, Ugo, Kashmir, una Palestina sull’Himalaya, https//ugotramballi.blog.ilsole24ore.com, 9 agosto 2019

Tyab, Imtiaz, Pakistan re-arrests terror group founder Hafiz Saeed before Prime Minister Imran Khan’s meeting with Trump, “cbsnews”, 17 luglio 2019

Tyagi, Gaurav, The Truth behind Pulwama & Balakot – The road ahead, southasiajournal.net, 20 aprile 2019

Van Schendel, Willem (2009), A History of Bangladesh, Cambridge University Press

Published
2019-12-30
Section
ItINERARI